© Reuters.  In next war, soldiers will leave their smartphones at home: Peter Apps © Reuters. In next war, soldiers will leave their smartphones at home: Peter Apps

By Peter Apps

LONDON (Reuters) - As the 1st Brigade Combat Team of the U.S. 82nd Airborne Division departed for the Middle East amid rising tensions with Iran, their divisional commander gave a simple order. All personnel entering the region were told to leave smartphones and personal devices in the United States.

It was a clear sign of growing official nervousness over the potential vulnerability of items that had become an unquestioned fact of life for soldiers and civilians alike, but which Washington fears potential foes could track, exploit and use for targeting. Such concerns are far from new, but were regarded less seriously when America's primary enemies were seen as non-state groups such as Islamic State, the Taliban and al Qaeda. Now Washington is worried about other nations – not just Iran, but Russia and China – which are seen as a much more existential threat.

It also points to a much greater trend. Across the board, the communications revolution – and the vast sea of data it produces – has made surveillance much easier, a trend likely to be magnified by the growth of artificial intelligence. It has also facilitated the mass leaking of phenomenal amounts of information, as demonstrated by NSA contractor Edward Snowden. And simultaneously, it has overturned decades of tradecraft in espionage and associated fields, where despite the rise in "fake news" and online trickery, spy agencies like the CIA now reportedly find it almost impossible to maintain the multiple false identities on which they once relied.

"The foundations of the business of espionage have been shattered," former CIA official Duyane Norman said in a Yahoo (NASDAQ:AABA) news report, which outlined how foreign governments have become much better at tracking real and covert U.S. identities through phone and bank records, facial recognition and even the records of off-the-shelf DNA tests. "The debate [within the intelligence community] is like the one surrounding climate change. Anyone who says otherwise just isn't looking at the facts."


For military commanders, the options are also becoming limited. In Russia's war with Ukraine, Moscow's forces have shown remarkable skill in targeting counterparts on the battlefield as soon as they use their phones or radios. According to the U.S.-based Military Times, the U.S. Marine Corps already bans troops from taking personal devices on Middle East combat deployments. The U.S. Navy says it is reconsidering its rules, while the Army says such decisions - as with the 82nd Airborne - are at the personal discretion of commanders.

Decisions are inevitably compromises. Taking away devices reduces the ability of personnel not just to talk to their families, but can complicate communications and organization. But concerns are growing fast. This month, the Pentagon also demanded personnel stop using the Chinese-owned TikTok application, with other similar platforms including WhatsApp also added to some blacklists.

Reducing "careless talk" and unnecessary radio and other emissions is hardly new. As far back as World War One, British commanders discovered telephone systems in forward trenches had often been compromised by German signallers and did everything they could to ensure the most sensitive messages were instead carried by hand or word-of-mouth. Naval vessels, military aircraft and particularly submarines have long done everything possible to mask their signatures, particularly near enemy territory. Recent years, however, have seen growing lapses, including from those who might have been expected to know better.


In early 2018, data released by fitness app Strava identified assorted U.S., Russian and even Iranian secret bases in Syria where military personnel and contractors appeared to have recorded their exercise runs without realizing they would be highlighted and widely shared. The U.S. military has now gone so far as to incorporate such mistakes into training exercises, killing off an entire unit in one drill after a soldier posted a selfie photo whose geo-tagging gave away their position.

Authorities are also nervous about non-accidental release of information. This November, White House and military staff removed smartphones from reporters and presidential aides for the duration of President Donald Trump's unannounced Thanksgiving trip to Afghanistan, which appeared as much about ensuring the news did not leak as worries the phones themselves might be tracked.

In terms of the latter, the greatest threat will come when artificial intelligence and voice recognition software reach the point where phones can be used to monitor nearby conversations without use of a human analyst or translator. That may come sooner rather than later – one reason why some security experts are extremely nervous about Chinese firm Huawei being at the heart of 5G phone networks in several European countries. That may include Britain, due to make its own choice soon. This week, the head of Britain's Security Service told the Financial Times he believed that risk can be managed without barring the Chinese firm altogether. U.S. counterparts, however, are much more cautious.

For authoritarian states like China and Iran, both witnessing a major spike in often smartphone-coordinated protest and unrest, being able to access and track electronic devices – and the population at large – is seen as a priority. Most notably in Xinjiang province but also across the country, Beijing is turning China into the most sophisticated surveillance state in human history. Within its borders, China already has considerable, sometimes almost exhaustive, access to data and devices. Faster and more incisive artificial intelligence and machine learning will dramatically extend that reach.

The question for Western states will be how effectively their potential foes can repurpose that technology to gather information outside their borders. The United States and its allies have become used to being able to use whatever devices and communications they wished since the Berlin wall fell. Those days are ending fast.

*** Peter Apps is a writer on international affairs, localization, conflict and other issues. He is the founder and executive director of the Project for Study of the 21st Century; PS21, a non-national, non-partisan, non-ideological think tank. Paralysed by a war-zone car crash in 2006, he also blogs about his disability and other topics. Hewas previously areporter for Reuters and continues to be paid by ThomsonReuters. Since 2016, he has been a member of the British Army Reserve and the UK Labour Party, and is an active fundraiser for the party.

(The opinions expressed here are those of the author, a columnist for Reuters)

Other relevant articles 
[2020-01-14 13:15:13] U.S. bike firms face uphill slog to replace Chinese supply chains
[2020-01-14 13:05:05] JPMorgan profit gets boost from trading, underwriting
[2020-01-14 13:00:08] JPMorgan Earnings, Revenue Beat in Q4
[2020-01-14 13:00:08] Breaking: JPMorgan Q4 Earnings Blow Past Expectations
[2020-01-14 12:45:05] SNB Franc Shock Reverberates in Negative Rates, U.S. Critics
[2020-01-14 12:30:05] U.S. Small-Business Optimism Retreats From a Four-Month High
[2020-01-14 12:20:08] Top 5 Things to Know in the Market on Tuesday, 14th January
[2020-01-14 12:15:04] India central bank may put rate cuts on extended pause after...
[2020-01-14 12:10:04] Ryanair says could see first Boeing 737 MAX deliveries in April
[2020-01-14 12:10:04] With time running out, Democratic presidential contenders to meet...
[2020-01-14 12:05:04] Xi Strikes Optimistic Tone After Riding Out Trade War With Trump
[2020-01-14 12:05:04] Bank for International Settlements sees first expansion since...
[2020-01-14 12:00:14] Nokia lowers cost cut target to invest in 5G and digitalization
[2020-01-14 11:40:04] RBS Predicts Interest-Rate Cut This Month After BOE’s Dovish...
[2020-01-14 11:30:05] Ford invests $82 million to expand Vietnamese plant
[2020-01-14 11:25:03] European Stocks Drop at Open; U.S. Banks Earnings Eyed
[2020-01-14 11:10:03] Stabilizing euro zone growth vindicates ECB: Mersch
[2020-01-14 11:05:04] StockBeat: Red Metal Rally Keeps Mining Sector in the Green
[2020-01-14 11:00:09] BlackRock threatens backlash against firms who delay climate...
[2020-01-14 10:20:04] Travel app Omio the latest Berlin startup to take on North...
[2020-01-14 10:15:09] Swiss National Bank under rising pressure after five years of...
[2020-01-14 10:10:05] Pound on Longest Losing Streak Since May on BOE Easing Talk
[2020-01-14 10:10:05] Britain bans using credit cards to gamble
[2020-01-14 10:05:03] Hong Kong pledges $1.3 billion in economic relief amid unrest
[2020-01-14 10:00:09] European Stocks Drop at Open; U.S. Banks Earnings Eyed
[2020-01-14 10:00:09] Ahead of Bezos visit, India antitrust chief says e-commerce firms...
[2020-01-14 09:50:04] European shares inch lower ahead of Sino-U.S. trade deal; fourth quarter...
[2020-01-14 09:45:17] China steel mills cut back on high-grade iron ore as margins slump
[2020-01-14 09:40:04] China December trade beats forecasts: exports up 7.6%, imports up...
[2020-01-14 09:40:04] At least three Chinese automakers eyeing expansion in Mexico
[2020-01-14 09:40:04] China rare earth exports rebound in December, but annual...
[2020-01-14 09:40:04] China posts strong December exports as world awaits Sino-U.S....
[2020-01-14 09:40:04] Crude exports boom on U.S. Gulf Coast, allaying bottleneck fears
[2020-01-14 09:35:03] Yuan, stocks rally as investors bet on imminent U.S.-China deal...
[2020-01-14 09:35:03] Canadian court denies media request to broadcast Huawei CFO...
[2020-01-14 09:35:03] Nissan says not considering dissolving alliance with Renault
[2020-01-14 09:35:03] World’s Largest Wealth Manager Tells Investors: Lower...
[2020-01-14 09:35:03] China to ramp up U.S. car, aircraft, energy purchases in trade deal: source
[2020-01-14 09:30:05] Forex - Dollar Mixed as U.S. Drops China "Manipulator" Label
[2020-01-14 09:05:06] Premarket London: Taylor Wimpey Sees Stable Market; Elementis...
[2020-01-14 08:50:03] Europe Open: DAX Set To Underperform; U.S. Bank Earnings Eyed
[2020-01-14 08:45:04] DAX Set To Underperform; US Banks in view
[2020-01-14 07:20:03] Oil Prices Gain; Iran Protests, Imminent Signing of U.S.-China Trade Deal in...
[2020-01-14 07:05:03] Gold Prices Down Amid Anticipation of U.S.-China Phase One Deal
[2020-01-14 06:45:05] Hong Kong Funds Eye Singapore Offices to Dodge Protest Woes
[2020-01-14 06:40:03] Saudi, U.A.E. Banks to See Jump in Loan Demand as Profit Lags
[2020-01-14 06:40:03] Thailand Is Ready to Take More Steps to Rein In Its Currency
[2020-01-14 06:30:23] China’s Exports, Imports Both Rise in 2019
[2020-01-14 05:15:04] FX Manipulator No More, Spiraling Debt, Hong Kong Hope: Eco Day
[2020-01-14 05:15:04] Bonds Set to Drop in India After Inflation Jumps to Five-Year...
[2020-01-14 05:10:04] How the World’s Fastest-Growing Economy Plunged Into Stagflation
[2020-01-14 05:10:04] China’s 2019 Exports Edged Up as Total Trade With U.S. Declined
[2020-01-14 05:05:03] Johnson’s Next Brexit Fight Looms on EU’s Fishing Access Demands
[2020-01-14 04:40:06] Asian Markets Rise as U.S. Drops China’s Currency Manipulator...
[2020-01-14 02:10:27] U.S. stocks higher at close of trade; Dow Jones Industrial Average up 0.29%
[2020-01-13 23:35:24] Day Ahead: Top 3 Things to Watch for Jan. 14
[2020-01-13 23:05:31] Hong Kong Pins Hopes on Trade, Finance to Restore Economy
[2020-01-13 23:00:30] Visa in Deal to Buy Plaid for $5.3 billion.
[2020-01-13 22:30:25] Post-Brexit Trade Deal Contingent on Fisheries Accord, EU Says
[2020-01-13 22:20:29] Stocks - S&P, Nasdaq Hit All-Time Highs as Tech Continues to Shine
[2020-01-13 22:15:24] Stocks - S&P, Nasdaq Hit All-Time Highs as Tech Continues to Shine
[2020-01-13 21:30:25] Roku Jumps as It Impresses in Las Vegas
[2020-01-13 21:20:24] Gold Blows Away More Froth, But Retains $1,500 Grip
[2020-01-13 21:15:24] Nvidia Climbs as Analyst Sees Continued Growth in Gaming
[2020-01-13 20:45:24] U.S. Budget Deficit Widens 11.8% in First Quarter of Fiscal Year
[2020-01-13 20:25:23] Health Insurers Hit With Bernie Sanders Leading in Iowa
[2020-01-13 19:50:25] OIl’s Losses Deepen; Oversupply Feared Above Iran Tensions, China...
[2020-01-13 19:20:27] Tech Leads Stocks to Record Highs; Bonds Decline: Markets Wrap
[2020-01-13 19:20:27] StockBeat : Apple Continues March Into Record Territory on...
[2020-01-13 19:10:23] Vanguard’s 1% U.S. Growth Call Is Rooted in Bond Market’s Wisdom
[2020-01-13 18:30:25] Tesla Stock Tops $500 for First Time; China, Analyst Enthusiasm...
[2020-01-13 18:25:50] U.S. to Lift Yuan Manipulator Tag Ahead of China Trade Deal
[2020-01-13 18:20:23] Tesla Stock Tops $500 for First Time; China, Analyst Enthusiasm...
[2020-01-13 17:55:23] Tech Sector Leads Stocks Higher; Bonds Decline: Markets Wrap
[2020-01-13 16:05:23] Wall Street Pushes Higher Amid Deal Flurry
[2020-01-13 15:35:29] Oil Holds Biggest Weekly Loss Since July on Easing Gulf Tension
[2020-01-13 15:30:25] Russian Billionaire Loses Lawsuit Against Nordic Banks
[2020-01-13 15:00:28] Stocks: Lululemon up in Premarket on Strong Q4; Alphabet Eyes $1 Trln Mark
[2020-01-13 14:55:22] Commodities Week Ahead: China Set To Sign, But Will Deal Help Gold And Oil?
[2020-01-13 14:45:24] Stocks: Lululemon up in Premarket on Strong Q4; Alphabet Eyes $1 Trln Mark
[2020-01-13 14:35:22] Stocks: Lululemon Higher in Premarket on Strong 4Q; WCC to Buy Anixter
[2020-01-13 14:10:27] Stocks: Lululemon Higher in Premarket After 4Q Upgrade
[2020-01-13 14:00:28] Goldman Readies a Hiring Spree and Capital to Meet Its China...
[2020-01-13 13:55:26] Opening Bell: U.S. Futures, Global Stocks Rise Ahead Of Trade Deal,...
[2020-01-13 13:35:25] Europe Looks to Follow China’s Lead Taming Trump on Trade
[2020-01-13 13:20:35] Wall Street to head higher; Boeing in focus
[2020-01-13 13:15:24] Infosys Drives India’s Sensex to Record After 3Q Earnings Beat
[2020-01-13 13:10:22] Turkey Stocks Trade Near Record in Sign of Renewed Risk Appetite
[2020-01-13 12:25:44] Top 5 Things to Know in the Market on Monday
[2020-01-13 12:20:23] India stocks higher at close of trade; Nifty 50 up 0.59%
[2020-01-13 11:30:27] UK economy contracts; Sterling weakens
[2020-01-13 11:10:28] U.K. Economy Unexpectedly Shrinks Amid BOE Rate-Cut Debate
[2020-01-13 10:05:22] Stocks - Europe Opens Higher as Macro Backdrop Improves
[2020-01-13 09:20:23] Forex - Sterling Slips vs Dollar, Euro as Vlieghe Fuels Rate...
[2020-01-13 07:30:24] Safe-Haven Gold Slips as Asian Stocks Gain Ahead of Trade Deal Signing
[2020-01-13 07:20:28] Electric Car Stocks Jump as China Signals Lull in Subsidy Cuts
[2020-01-13 07:20:28] India Is Creating Fewer Jobs For World’s Biggest Workforce
[2020-01-13 06:45:23] Oil Prices Slip Amid Easing U.S.-Iran Tensions; Traders Await Signing of Trade...
[2020-01-13 06:05:24] Forex - U.S. Dollar Flat Ahead of Inflation Data, Trade Deal Signing in Focus
[2020-01-13 05:15:24] Asian Markets Rise Ahead of U.S.-China Phase One Deal Signing