f
  •  
© Reuters.  Trump Doesn’t Understand Currency Wars, Either © Reuters. Trump Doesn’t Understand Currency Wars, Either

(Bloomberg Opinion) -- What a difference a decade makes. Back in September 2010, Guido Mantega, Brazil’s then-finance minister, was complaining bitterly about “currency wars,” and claiming the Federal Reserve’s ultra-loose monetary policy of the time was unfairly hurting his economy. “We’re in the midst of an international currency war, a general weakening of currency,” he said then. “This threatens us because it takes away our competitiveness.”

Fast forward to December 2019, and we have President Donald Trump’s latest furious denunciation of exactly the same thing —only this time, he says that Brazil (as well as Argentina) is being unfair. In his latest tweet heard around the world, he said: “Brazil and Argentina have been presiding over a massive devaluation of their currencies. which is not good for our farmers.”

After announcing the imposition of tariffs on Brazilian and Argentine steel, he went on to attack the Fed. He wants the central bankto return to the behavior that so annoyed Mantega a decade ago: “The Federal Reserve should likewise act so that countries, of which there are many, no longer take advantage of our strong dollar by further devaluing their currencies. This makes it very hard for our manufactures & farmers to fairly export their goods. Lower Rates & Loosen - Fed!”

If Mantega’s complaints look dumb in retrospect, Trump’s latest broadside looksevendumber. Mantega’s complaint came when Brazil’s economy was surging on the back of strong commodity prices (which themselves were driven by the voracious manufacturing appetite of China). The strong Brazilian real hadn’tstopped the country’seconomy from going on a great run. In the subsequent decade, the U.S. far outstripped Brazil’s growth, despite a steadily strengthening dollar:

Currency valuesmattergreatly to competitiveness, of course, and central banks can use interest rates to manipulate them. But the arrow of causation also works in the other direction. A weak economy will lead to a weak currency, and vice versa. That is the story of the U.S.dollar and the Brazilian real over the last decade.

The weak dollar in 2010 was a product of the weakness of the U.S. economy. Low rates and quantitative easing were deemed necessary to keep the economy ticking over, and allow the country to clear its debts. Outright deflation appeared a real risk. Higher rates from the Fed at that point might have weakened the real, but they might also have stopped U.S. economic growth in its tracks —which would have been very bad news for Brazil.

Is Brazilmanipulating its currency lower? Not at all. Its central bank’s target rate, the Selic, is very low at present, by Brazilian standards, but only because inflation is at its lowest this century:

Further, as the country’s use of dollar-denominated debt has increased over the last decade, a weak real makes interest payments more expensive and increases the risk of a crisis.

No country knows this better than Argentina, which has suffered several epic crises of devaluation and default in living memory, and where voters have just kicked out a president, Mauricio Macri,in large part for failing to tame inflation. Macri failedto stop further sharp devaluations of the Argentine peso, despite massive overnight rates of more than 50%. Another disadvantage of a weak currency is inflation, and Argentines know all about that. It too is currently running at more than 50%. Any implication that Argentina is deliberately weakening its currency for competitive advantage is beyond absurdity.

In the long run, the currency war has had only one winner. GDP per capita in both Brazil and Argentina is less than a quarter that of the U.S. And both countries have fallen further behind, even as their currencies have weakened.

Why, then, is Trump choosing to open a new front in the trade war, on two countries that currently have little or no ability to harm the U.S.? It is possible that he is being “crazy like a fox,” and trying to convince people that he is capable of anything. Such a strategy, the argument goes, might convince China of the need to do what he wants. The risk with such a strategy is to give the appearance that he has no understandingof how the economy works. And thus the more likely explanation for his behavior is that he truly doesn’tunderstand what he is doing.

Meanwhile, Brazil and Argentina have shown the U.S. the best way to weaken a currency. If your economy slows down, the chances are that your currency will get cheaper. That is what has happened over the last decade to the big economies of South America. And in the much shorter term, the sharp sell-off in the dollar on Monday in response to disappointing data on manufacturing suggests that the president should be careful what he wishes for. Today’s weak Brazilian real appears to be exactly what Guido Mantega wished for back in 2010 —but nobody in Brazil could possibly have wished for the disastrous decade that made that weak currency possible.


Other relevant articles 
[2019-12-02 19:20:26] Trump’s New Metal Moves Show There’s No Safety From ?Tariff Man’
[2019-12-02 17:45:26] Gold Prices Recover Losses as Trump, Ross Talk up Tariff Threat
[2019-12-02 17:40:28] Steel Companies Jump After Trump Hits Brazil and Argentina with...
[2019-12-02 16:30:26] Trump says China wants to make trade deal
[2019-12-02 16:10:33] Stocks - Wall Street Falters After Trump Revives Steel Tariffs 
[2019-12-02 13:25:24] Trump Revives Brazil, Argentina Steel Tariffs, Swipes at Fed
[2019-12-02 13:15:24] Stocks - U.S. Futures Rise on Strong Holiday Sales, Trump Damps Mood
[2019-12-02 13:10:24] Stocks - U.S. Futures  Held Back as Trump Implements Steel Tariffs
[2019-12-02 13:05:23] Trump says he will restore tariffs on Brazil, Argentina metal...
[2019-12-02 12:25:28] Trump says he will restore tariffs on Brazil, Argentina metal...
[2019-12-01 21:20:30] Trump off to London for NATO summit, under pressure to steer...
[2019-12-01 12:10:22] Trump faces two impeachment deadlines as inquiry shifts focus
[2019-11-29 19:30:14] Gold up as Trump’s Hong Kong Gambit Seen Hurting Trade Deal
[2019-11-29 18:55:12] StockBeat: Semis Swing Lower as U.S.-China Trade Sours; Trump...
[2019-11-29 18:45:14] Oil Plunges on Black Friday as Russia Stuns OPEC, Trump Angers...
[2019-11-29 18:35:19] Oil Plunges on Black Friday as Russia Stuns OPEC, Trump Angers...
[2019-11-29 17:05:12] NATO moves towards spending goal sought by Trump, Spain lags
[2019-11-29 13:05:20] Stocks - U.S. Futures Slip After Trump Signs Hong Kong Bill
[2019-11-29 11:50:35] UK PM Johnson implores Trump: please keep out of election
[2019-11-29 11:30:15] UK PM Johnson implores Trump: please avoid the election
[2019-11-29 06:20:19] Japan Won’t Sign China-Backed Trade Deal If India Doesn’t Join
[2019-11-28 21:40:11] Trump makes surprise Afghanistan trip, voices hope for ceasefire
[2019-11-28 20:35:19] Trump makes surprise Afghan trip, voices hope for ceasefire
[2019-11-28 20:35:19] Trump makes surprise Thanksgiving trip to Afghanistan
[2019-11-28 12:30:10] The Big Question on Hong Kong: How Will China Hit Back at Trump?
[2019-11-28 11:25:08] Trump Signs Hong Kong Bill Backing Protesters, Angering China
[2019-11-28 07:40:13] EU’s Anti-Trump Trade Champion Bids Farewell: Brussels Edition
[2019-11-28 07:35:08] Trump Signs Hong Kong Bill Backing Protesters, Angering China
[2019-11-28 07:30:10] Forex - Yen Inches Up, Dollar Flat as Trump Signs Hong Kong Bill
[2019-11-28 04:45:09] Asian Markets Mixed; Chinese Stocks Down as Trump Signs Bill...
[2019-11-28 01:45:13] Yen rises, yuan falls after Trump signs Hong Kong protest bill
[2019-11-27 21:40:12] Oil Dips; Trade Deal Hopes Offset Crude Build
[2019-11-27 08:30:10] Trump says near deal with China, but U.S. also has eye on Hong...
[2019-11-27 07:55:08] Asian shares climb as Trump says U.S. China trade deal near
[2019-11-26 21:50:07] U.S. House Judiciary panel invites Trump to December 4 impeachment hearing
[2019-11-26 20:25:05] Trump Says China Deal in ?Final Throes’ as Top Officials Speak
[2019-11-26 18:30:06] Activist investor seeks to oust Trump friend Barrack from CEO job...
[2019-11-26 18:10:07] Trump says near deal with China, but U.S. also has eye on Hong...
[2019-11-26 16:35:05] In gesture to Trump, US allies close to deal to pay more for NATO...
[2019-11-26 00:50:28] U.S. Supreme court extends block on Trump financial records...
[2019-11-25 23:00:38] U.S. prosecutors seek information on payments to Trump lawyer...
[2019-11-25 20:30:27] Americans, not Chinese, pay Trump tariffs: NY Fed study
[2019-11-25 19:40:34] Trump says he still has confidence in Mulvaney
[2019-11-25 12:25:22] On Trump impeachment, divisions between urban and rural Democrats
[2019-11-24 18:35:19] Senior Democrat says next step underway in Trump impeachment...
[2019-11-23 11:55:14] Trump Pledged to Help Small Farms. Aid Is Going to Big Ones
[2019-11-22 21:15:13] Gold Steady as Trump, Xi Telegraph More Trade Uncertainty
[2019-11-22 21:05:12] NewsBreak: Trump Looks to Let Florida, Others Import Prescription Drugs
[2019-11-22 20:50:12] NewsBreak: Trump: U.S. to Let Florida, Others Import Prescription...
[2019-11-22 20:30:13] Trump says his administration will determine an age for...
[2019-11-22 20:05:12] What comes next in the Trump impeachment inquiry?
[2019-11-22 19:15:12] Trump acknowledges Pompeo could run for U.S. Senate
[2019-11-22 19:00:19] Trump says he alone stopped massive Chinese crackdown on Hong...
[2019-11-22 18:10:11] Trump accuses impeachment witness of lying, defends use of...
[2019-11-22 17:50:15] More foreign firms abandoned U.S. deals amid Trump administration...
[2019-11-22 17:15:12] Trump Says He Saved Hong Kong by Threatening China in Trade Talk
[2019-11-22 15:30:12] Trump says will stick with Vice President Pence as 2020 running mate
[2019-11-22 02:00:14] Trump wants Senate trial, expects Joe Biden to testify: White...
[2019-11-22 00:10:12] Trump Pledged to Help Small Farms. Aid Is Going to Big Ones
[2019-11-22 00:05:11] Trump Pledged to Help Small Farms. Aid Is Going to Big Ones
[2019-11-21 21:05:08] House panel urges U.S. Supreme Court not to protect Trump...
[2019-11-21 20:30:09] Trump administration mulls new EU trade probe as auto tariff...
[2019-11-21 20:20:08] Schwab-TD Ameritrade deal shows Trump rule-easing boon for...
[2019-11-21 19:15:09] 15 U.S. senators urge Trump administration to halt Huawei license...
[2019-11-21 14:40:08] Trump wants Apple to be involved in 5G infrastructure building in U.S.
[2019-11-21 13:15:08] Exclusive: Trump administration to miss 2019 target for Alaska refuge oil lease sale - official
[2019-11-21 00:30:12] Defense Dept official says she never discussed Ukraine aid with...
[2019-11-21 00:10:14] EU Doubts Trump Will Follow Up on Threat of Tariffs on Car...
[2019-11-20 23:30:16] Trump says looking at whether Apple should be exempt from China...
[2019-11-20 23:10:13] Notes in hand, Trump states his case about impeachment
[2019-11-20 23:10:13] Fed shows little appetite for bold policy change sought by Trump
[2019-11-20 21:55:27] Gold Steady Second Day Amid Trump Ambiguity on Trade Deal
[2019-11-20 18:10:08] Trump says U.S., China trade talks continue
[2019-11-20 13:05:07] Stocks - U.S. Futures Fall as Trump Reiterates China Tariff Threats 
[2019-11-20 07:10:07] Why Gordon Sondland is key witness in Trump impeachment hearings
[2019-11-20 05:00:14] Asian Markets Slip as Trump Threatens Higher Tariffs
[2019-11-20 00:40:27] An officer and an impeachment witness, he draws ire of Trump...
[2019-11-19 21:25:04] Gold Holds Steady As Trump Warns China on Trade Deal
[2019-11-19 19:35:04] Two Officials Say Trump Ukraine Call Was Unusual, Inappropriate
[2019-11-19 19:35:04] Two Officials Say Trump Ukraine Call Was Unusual, Inappropriate
[2019-11-19 19:30:05] Without a China trade deal, the U.S. will hike tariffs: Trump
[2019-11-19 19:25:04] NewsBreak: Trump Threatens to Hike Tariffs on China
[2019-11-19 18:35:03] Without a China trade deal, the U.S. will hike tariffs: Trump
[2019-11-19 18:20:04] Trump says Pelosi delaying vote on new trade pact to get...
[2019-11-19 07:10:03] Japan’s Lower House Passes U.S. Trade Deal Sought by Trump
[2019-11-18 21:20:23] Gold Edges up on Chinese Worry Over Trump Impeachment
[2019-11-18 19:25:22] U.S. Supreme Court puts temporary hold on Trump financial records...
[2019-11-18 18:50:23] Powell Meets Trump, Mnuchin to Discuss Economy in Rare Sit-Down
[2019-11-18 17:50:23] House investigating whether Trump lied in U.S. Russia probe: CNN
[2019-11-18 17:15:47] Trump and Powell met Monday at White House to discuss economy
[2019-11-18 16:05:22] Trump tweets he might be willing to testify in impeachment...
[2019-11-18 15:15:23] Trump says he will consider testifying in impeachment hearing
[2019-11-17 18:10:26] In Trump-Nixon impeachment comparison, Pelosi raises specter of...
[2019-11-16 11:10:14] Trump asked Tokyo for $8 billion to keep U.S. troops in Japan:...
[2019-11-15 21:55:18] Trump, Apple CEO Tim Cook set to tour computer plant in Texas...
[2019-11-15 21:05:13] Republican Elise Stefanik tangles with Schiff to defend Trump...
[2019-11-15 21:00:23] Trump asks Supreme Court to block disclosure of financial records...
[2019-11-15 17:25:13] Michael Bloomberg to launch $100 million digital anti-Trump...
[2019-11-15 15:15:23] Trump to attend NATO meeting in Britain early December: White House
[2019-11-15 11:10:36] Automakers around world await Trump tariff decision