f
  •  

By Hallie Gu and Tom Westbrook

BEIJING/SINGAPORE (Reuters) - Commodity traders and analysts are struggling to map out how China will reach the eye-popping amounts it is committing to buy from the United States under Phase 1 of their trade deal.

China has pledged to buy $50 billion more in U.S. energy supplies, and will raise U.S. agriculture purchases by some $32 billion over two years above 2017's $24 billion baseline, according to a source briefed on the deal to be signed on Wednesday. The deal also stipulates purchases of an additional $80 billion in manufactured goods.

Those totals would certainly trim the roughly $300 billion annual trade gap between the countries. However, analysts who study Chinese commodity flows remain skeptical that Beijing can absorb such quantities of U.S. goods without threatening trade ties with other suppliers, hurting its own domestic producers, and making substantial changes to import standards and quotas.

“Either China massively increases imports and reduces current account surplus from the current 1.5% of GDP, or it engages in trade diversion away from current providers of goods which compete with the U.S." said Alicia Garcia Herrero, Chief Economist Asia Pacific at Natixis in Hong Kong. "I see this second scenario as much more likely."

ENERGY

China will have to include U.S. crude, liquefied natural gas (LNG) shipments and imports of petrochemical raw materials such as ethane and liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) to meet the target, Chinese trade sources and analysts said.

But it would still struggle unless new supply deals are signed that displace other exporters, they said.

The $50 billion target is "too aggressive and unlikely to achieve", said Seng Yick Tee, an analyst at SIA Energy in Beijing, adding that energy product exports from the United States to China were about $8 billion in 2017 and 2018.

"To achieve $25 billion a year, all the imports need to be tripled."

Gavin Thompson, Vice Chair for Asia Pacific at Wood Mackenzie, was surprised by the energy figure since it would mean tariffs on U.S. crude and LNG imports would have to be removed, particularly for LNG to be competitive.

Quality, rather than quantity, may be another hurdle.

"Most of the Chinese refineries were designed to process medium-sour crude, but U.S. oil is mostly light, sweet," SIA's Tee said, referring to the density and the sulfur amounts in crude, which dictate the types of fuels that can be refined from an oil.

AGRICULTURE TARGET "SHOCKING"

The pledge to boost U.S. farm imports by over $30 billion over two years is "shocking" since that increment is more than the value of farm products it has purchased from the U.S. in a single year, said a China-based grains trader.

"It would make (more) sense if the $32 billion is the total number, not the increased number."

Such a large fixed dollar-figure from one producer would also risk supply disruptions and distort international crop prices, said Iris Pang, Greater China economist at ING in Hong Kong.

"Prices of agri (commodities) from the rest of the world could be cheaper, especially after China cut import tariffs (in January). So even after retaliatory tariffs are removed, the U.S. will not have a competitive advantage over other economies," she said.

Traders also questioned what products China could buy from the United States since African swine fever has dented demand for soybeans for animal feed and quotas to protect domestic farmers limit grain imports.

"China will, for sure, buy more soybeans, let's say, 30 to 40 million tonnes. (For) wheat, maybe we can increase purchases within the import quota," said a trader with a Chinese grain importer.

A third grains trader said: "If such volume (of products) come to China, it will be a disaster for us (in the domestic market)."


Other relevant articles 
[2020-01-14 07:05:03] Gold Prices Down Amid Anticipation of U.S.-China Phase One Deal
[2020-01-13 07:20:28] EM Review: Phase-One Deal Hope Fueled Rally as Iran Risk Eased
[2020-01-13 06:20:25] EM Review: Phase-One Trade Deal Hope Fuels Asset Rally
[2020-01-13 05:15:24] Asian Markets Rise Ahead of U.S.-China Phase One Deal Signing
[2020-01-10 17:55:11] As White House plans U.S.-China Phase 1 ceremony, still no final...
[2020-01-09 18:10:08] Trump says he may wait to finish Phase 2 China trade deal until...
[2020-01-03 07:15:12] U.S. farmers see another bleak year despite Phase 1 trade deal
[2019-12-30 17:45:24] White House adviser says China trade deal signing expected soon
[2019-12-19 08:55:07] China says in touch with U.S. on signing of Phase 1 trade deal
[2019-12-16 15:10:23] Goldman Sachs raises 12-month commodity returns forecast
[2019-12-16 10:20:22] What’s in the U.S.-China Phase One Deal and What’s Still Missing
[2019-12-16 10:15:24] Stocks rise as investors cheer preliminary U.S.-China trade deal
[2019-12-16 06:50:22] Oil Price Fall as Phase One Trade Deal Offers Little Support
[2019-12-16 04:50:37] Asian Markets Mixed as Lighthizer Says No Date is Set for Phase...
[2019-12-15 17:10:28] Can Palladium Win The Award For Best Performing Commodity In 2019?
[2019-12-13 19:15:12] U.S. and China Agree to ?Phase-One’ Deal Easing Trade Tensions
[2019-12-13 19:15:12] U.S. and China Agree to ?Phase-One’ Deal Easing Trade Tensions
[2019-12-13 16:25:11] China Claims "Consensus" Reached on Text of Phase-1 Deal
[2019-12-13 16:15:12] NewsBreak: China Claims "Consensus" Reached on Text of Phase-1...
[2019-12-13 06:50:11] Gold Prices Slip on News of Phase One Trade News; U.K. Election in Focus
[2019-12-13 04:45:11] Asian Markets Jump as Trump Approves Phase-One U.S.-China Trade...
[2019-12-10 16:05:04] Mulvaney says trajectory toward Phase 1 U.S.-China trade deal...
[2019-12-05 09:30:13] China maintains tariffs must be reduced for phase one trade deal with U.S.
[2019-12-04 13:50:18] Futures jump on report of U.S., China nearing phase-one trade...
[2019-12-04 11:50:09] U.S. and China move closer to phase-one trade deal: Bloomberg
[2019-12-04 10:35:11] U.S. and China move closer to phase-one trade deal - Bloomberg
[2019-12-04 10:15:09] Derivatives industry asks regulators to clarify Libor phase-out...
[2019-12-03 18:15:06] WTO tussles over hard stop vs phase-out of appeals system
[2019-12-02 03:15:25] China wants U.S. tariffs rolled back in phase one trade deal: Global Times
[2019-12-01 03:25:22] China wants rollback of tariffs in phase one trade deal with...
[2019-11-26 16:50:06] Mexico to spend $44 billion on infrastructure in first phase of...
[2019-11-26 09:10:10] China, U.S. Hold Phone Call in Sign of Progress on Phase 1 Deal
[2019-11-25 17:50:23] China and U.S. moving closer to trade deal, but no agreement on...
[2019-11-23 19:15:16] U.S. and China can still clinch phase 1 deal by end year: U.S. national security...
[2019-11-22 18:30:13] Trump, Xi send positive signals on initial deal to defuse...
[2019-11-21 08:40:11] China says will strive to reach phase one trade deal with U.S.
[2019-11-19 05:55:26] Forex - U.S. Dollar Little Changed; Hopes for Phase One Trade Deal Recedes
[2019-11-15 06:10:12] U.S. Official Says First-Phase China Trade Talks in Final Stages
[2019-11-14 08:50:06] China holding in-depth talks with U.S. on phase one of trade deal
[2019-11-12 20:00:09] Oil Stays in the Black as Trump Offers Little on China Deal
[2019-11-12 13:50:04] As impeachment probe starts new phase, Trump promises another...
[2019-11-07 23:40:09] U.S. Says Phase-One China Deal Would Include Tariff Rollback
[2019-11-07 11:25:07] China says it has agreed with U.S. to cancel tariffs in phases
[2019-11-07 10:00:25] China says it has agreed with U.S. to cancel tariffs in phases
[2019-11-07 08:50:07] China Says It Agreed With U.S. to Roll Back Tariffs in Phases
[2019-11-01 13:00:16] Phase one trade deal with China is in good shape: U.S. Commerce...
[2019-10-24 19:25:16] U.S. VP Pence says Trump hopes to tackle China IP theft after...
[2019-10-24 13:45:09] White House aide: Phase one U.S.-China trade deal targets...
[2019-10-17 21:55:13] Toyota conducts final phase of recall to replace Takata airbag...
[2019-10-17 12:50:08] China says it hopes to reach phased trade pact with U.S. as soon as...
[2019-10-17 10:05:07] China says hopes to reach phased trade pact with U.S. as early as...
[2019-10-15 04:55:26] Asian Stocks Fall; China Wants More Talk Before Signing “Phase...
[2019-10-14 13:00:33] China wants more talks before signing Trumps Phase 1 deal: Bloomberg
[2019-10-14 12:35:22] China Wants More Talks Before Signing Trump’s ?Phase One’ Deal
[2019-10-14 11:10:23] German economy stuck in weak phase, crisis unlikely: ministry
[2019-10-14 10:20:23] German economy stuck in weak phase, crisis unlikely: economy...
[2019-10-11 23:55:23] What Does US-China Phase 1 Deal Mean?
[2019-10-11 22:15:12] Trump Says U.S.-China Reach Partial ?Phase One’ Trade Deal
[2019-10-11 22:05:13] Trump says U.S., China have reached substantial phase-1 trade...
[2019-10-11 19:05:12] Euronext plans cash-settled commodity contracts
[2019-10-09 18:10:12] In The Current Commodity Markets Flux, The Humble Orange Juice Rises Too
[2019-10-01 13:50:04] Brazil opens next phase of corruption probe into unnamed meatpacker
[2019-09-11 18:35:08] Egypt to start work on $2.4-billion telecom network for first...
[2019-05-22 19:30:22] SEC sets dates for first phase of disputed exchange pricing plan
[2019-05-19 06:20:21] Tight security as Indians vote in final phase of mammoth election
[2019-05-17 13:35:26] Samsung to spend more than $14 billion in second phase of China...
[2019-05-14 15:40:19] Small Canadian Tech Company Sets Sights On Next Big Cannabis Sector...
[2019-05-12 06:50:25] India votes in penultimate phase of seven-round general election
[2019-05-06 15:20:34] China central bank to implement reserve requirement ratio cuts in...
[2019-04-12 03:25:18] Dollar shored up by strong U.S. data, commodity currencies sag
[2019-04-09 02:30:36] Dollar sags as commodity currencies draw support from crude oil...
[2019-03-29 14:20:26] Commodity prices, investment poised to extend upswing
[2019-03-17 20:35:27] Shares in U.S. steel producers could rally along with commodity:...
[2019-03-17 13:55:25] Rouhani inaugurates four new phases of South Pars gas field
[2019-03-16 22:40:26] Venezuelas Guaido launches national tour in new phase to oust Maduro
[2019-03-07 06:40:14] Shanghai Construction Group to build first phase of Teslas Shanghai plant: media
[2019-02-18 00:10:34] Yemens warring parties agree on initial redeployment: U.N
[2019-02-11 19:15:34] EU targets palm oil for road fuel phase-out, but with exemptions
[2019-02-05 16:35:24] EU moves to make UK charge VAT on commodity trading include ICE...
[2019-02-04 06:30:30] Japan insurers to target China M&A in new phase after $50 billion overseas push
[2019-02-03 00:25:24] Top German conservative hints at slower coal phase-out in nod to...
[2019-01-28 08:05:35] German Economy Minister: Do not want imported nuclear power to...
[2019-01-28 07:40:30] German Economy Minister: Do not want imported nuclear power to...
[2019-01-21 19:30:31] Canadian railways ration space as commodity congestion problems...
[2019-01-09 11:41:29] U.S.-China trade talks boost European shares as commodity stocks, banks rally
[2019-01-09 11:30:25] Natural Gas Drops To Third 2018 Commodity Gainers Spot As Weather Warms
[2019-01-04 09:45:17] U.S.-China trade talks boost European shares as commodity stocks, banks rally
[2018-12-28 16:50:15] Natural Gas Drops To Third 2018 Commodity Gainers Spot As Weather...
[2018-12-12 18:15:23] Climate talks work on fair way to phase out coal use: Canada
[2018-11-20 23:50:10] British Columbia moves to phase out non-electric car sales by...
[2018-11-20 16:50:11] White Houses Kudlow: Tax reforms next phase wont happen in...
[2018-10-24 22:35:17] China slump, commodity costs cause Ford profit drop
[2018-10-23 08:40:10] TSE owner to start merger talks with commodity exchange: source
[2018-10-22 18:00:42] U.S. in fact-finding phase on Khashoggi: Kushner
[2018-10-19 09:30:23] HKEXs commodity trading platform QME starts trading on Friday
[2018-10-02 16:35:15] Trump Trade Deals Mean Different Things To Commodity Traders, Economists
[2018-09-25 09:45:10] Commodity stocks and Next rally support European shares
[2018-09-13 12:25:12] Qualcomm targets $16 billion in first phase of share buyback
[2018-09-10 20:05:27] Governor Cuomo directs phase-out of climate change pollutants in...